What is SAE (Simultaneous Authentication of Equals)?

The acronym SAE stands for Simultaneous Authentication of Equals and refers to a secure key negotiation and exchange method for password-based authentication methods. It is a variant of the Dragonfly key exchange protocol specified in RFC 7664, which in turn is based on Diffie-Hellmann key exchange.

Among other things, SAE is used in WPA3 (Wi-Fi Protected Access 3) and replaces the previous method of negotiating session keys using pre-shared keys. In addition, Simultaneous Authentication of Equals is used in IEEE 802.11s WLAN mesh networks during the peer discovery process. SAE improves the security of key exchange in the handshake process.

Even when weak passwords are used, authentication is protected. Dictionary or brute force attacks and attack methods such as KRACK (Key Reinstallation Attack) are virtually impossible when using Simultaneous Authentication of Equals.

What is NAT (Network Address Translation)?

The motivation for Simultaneous Authentication of Equals

WPA2-based WLANs are vulnerable to KRACK, an attack method on WPA2 encryption that became known in 2017. Attackers can gain possession of the keys and manipulate or read the transmitted data. KRACK exploits a vulnerability in the multi-stage handshake process for negotiating session keys.

Another common security problem in WLANs is that weak or very short passwords are used. These can be found out relatively quickly using a dictionary or brute-force attacks. SAE is intended to secure WLANs against these vulnerabilities and protect data traffic in mesh networks. Simultaneous Authentication of Equals increases security in the case of weak passwords and makes it impossible to draw conclusions about the keys used by recording the handshake.

In addition, the key exchange protocol supports Perfect Forward Secrecy (PFS) and prevents session keys from being reconstructed after the fact. Even the subsequent disclosure of a WLAN password does not allow recorded data packets to be decrypted.

How SAE Authentication works

SAE still uses matching passwords that clients use to gain access to a WLAN. However, a unique Pairwise Master Key (PMK) that is different for each client is derived from the passwords.

Despite the use of a password that is the same for all clients, each client receives its own PMK. Pairwise Transient Keys (PTK) are derived from the PMK by means of a four-way handshake between the WLAN client and the authentication server and are used for the actual encryption of the data.

The use of SAE Security – SAE Encryption

One of the most important applications of SAE is the authentication and encryption standard for WLANs WPA3. In WPA3, the method used by WPA2 to negotiate session keys with pre-shared keys is replaced by Simultaneous Authentication of Equals. Since keys are no longer transmitted over the radio links, it is virtually impossible to draw conclusions about the keys by reading the handshake.

Session keys between the WLAN client and access point can be negotiated securely. Perfect Forward Secrecy (PFS) also ensures that recorded data packets cannot be subsequently decrypted, even if an attacker comes into possession of a WLAN password.

SAE is also used in WLAN mesh networks. The IEEE 802.11s standard defines how WLAN devices connect to form a meshed WLAN. Peers use SAE during the discovery process and establish secure connections using the derived pairwise keys.

Misconceptions About Simultaneous Authentication of Equals

Despite the security benefits that SAE offers, there are some misconceptions about it. For example, many people believe that since SAE is based on certificates and public key infrastructure (PKI), it requires additional hardware and software. This is not true; a WPA2-SAE network does not require an external PKI or any special hardware or software.

What is the Dark Web?

Additionally, some people think SAE is not suitable for open networks, as it requires authentication of the station and the access point (AP). While this may be true in certain cases, WPA2-SAE provides support for open networks using external entities, such as RADIUS servers. These can authenticate users off-network, eliminating the need for authentication between the station and AP.

Finally, some people believe that SAE is insecure due to its use of certificates. This too is not true; WPA2-SAE has built in security measures to ensure the security of certificates. Furthermore, it is important to note that SAE does not require the use of certificates in any way; it simply provides an option for those who wish to use them.

What is SAE (Simultaneous Authentication of Equals) Really Means in Cyber Security?

In cybersecurity, SAE (Simultaneous Authentication of Equals) is a key establishment protocol used in Wi-Fi Protected Access 3 (WPA3) to secure wireless networks. SAE is a password-based protocol that allows two devices to securely establish a shared secret key without requiring a pre-shared key (PSK) or a Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) setup.

SAE is designed to prevent offline dictionary attacks and man-in-the-middle attacks that can compromise the security of Wi-Fi networks. It uses the Dragonfly key exchange protocol, which is resistant to password guessing attacks and provides forward secrecy, meaning that a compromise of one session key does not compromise the security of past or future sessions.

In essence, SAE is a secure and efficient way of establishing a shared key for wireless communication without the need for complex key management systems, making it a valuable tool in securing Wi-Fi networks.

What Is Sae Wifi?

SAE WiFi refers to the implementation of the Simultaneous Authentication of Equals (SAE) protocol in wireless networks to secure communications. SAE WiFi is used in Wi-Fi Protected Access 3 (WPA3) and is designed to provide enhanced security compared to previous versions of WPA.

With SAE WiFi, devices can establish a secure connection without the use of a pre-shared key (PSK) or public key infrastructure (PKI). Instead, SAE uses a password-based protocol to establish a shared secret key. This helps to prevent offline dictionary attacks and man-in-the-middle attacks that can compromise the security of Wi-Fi networks.

SAE WiFi uses the Dragonfly key exchange protocol, which provides forward secrecy and resistance to password guessing attacks. This means that even if an attacker manages to compromise one session key, they will not be able to access past or future sessions.

SAE WiFi is a more secure and efficient way to establish a shared key for wireless communication, making it a valuable tool in securing Wi-Fi networks.

What Is SAE Protocol

The SAE protocol is used in Wi-Fi Protected Access 3 (WPA3) to secure wireless networks. Unlike previous Wi-Fi security protocols, SAE uses a password-based approach to establish a shared secret key, without the need for pre-shared keys (PSK) or public key infrastructure (PKI) setups.

What is Security by Design?

SAE protocol uses the Dragonfly key exchange algorithm, which is designed to be resistant to password guessing attacks and provide forward secrecy. Forward secrecy ensures that a compromise of one session key does not compromise the security of past or future sessions.

Overall, the SAE protocol is a more secure and efficient way to establish a shared key for wireless communication, making it a valuable tool in securing Wi-Fi networks.

History of SAE

Simultaneous Authentication of Equals (SAE), also known as Dragonfly Key Exchange, was first introduced in 2010 by Dan Harkins as a proposed alternative to the widely used Pre-Shared Key (PSK) method for securing wireless networks. SAE was initially published as an Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) draft under the title “Dragonfly Key Exchange” in October 2010.

The goal of SAE was to provide a secure, password-based key exchange protocol that addresses the weaknesses of the PSK method, which has a number of vulnerabilities such as the need to share a single password among multiple clients, making it vulnerable to dictionary attacks and key theft.

The SAE protocol was later refined and standardized by the IEEE 802.11 working group, which is responsible for the development of the Wi-Fi standards. In 2018, the Wi-Fi Alliance adopted SAE as the key establishment protocol for the WPA3 security protocol, the latest version of the Wi-Fi Protected Access (WPA) standard.

Today, SAE is widely used in Wi-Fi networks and is considered to be a robust and secure key establishment protocol. It has become an essential component of modern Wi-Fi security, providing secure key generation and mutual authentication between clients and access points.

Advantages of SAE

Simultaneous Authentication of Equals (SAE) offers several advantages over the traditional Pre-Shared Key (PSK) method and other key establishment protocols. Some of the advantages of SAE include:

Stronger Security: SAE is designed to address the security weaknesses of the PSK method by providing a more secure and robust key establishment protocol. SAE uses a password-based authentication mechanism with a Diffie-Hellman key exchange to generate a unique session key for each client, making it much more difficult for attackers to compromise the network.
Protection Against Dictionary Attacks: SAE uses a hash function to derive a key from a shared password, which protects against dictionary attacks. The protocol ensures that even if an attacker is able to obtain the password, they will not be able to generate the same key as the legitimate parties.
Mutual Authentication: SAE provides mutual authentication between the client and access point, ensuring that both parties are legitimate and authorized to access the network.
Forward Secrecy: SAE provides forward secrecy, meaning that if a session key is compromised, it does not affect the security of previous or subsequent sessions. This provides an additional layer of security and helps to limit the impact of any potential security breaches.

Cyber Kill Chain: Understanding the Stages of a Cyber Attack

Compatibility with Existing Infrastructure: SAE is compatible with existing Wi-Fi infrastructure and can be implemented through a firmware update to support the protocol.

SAE offers a more secure and robust key establishment protocol for wireless networks, providing stronger protection against attacks and improving the overall security of the network.

Disadvantages of SAE

While Simultaneous Authentication of Equals (SAE) offers several advantages over other key establishment protocols, there are also some potential disadvantages to consider:

Compatibility Issues: Although SAE is designed to be compatible with existing Wi-Fi infrastructure, some older devices may not support the protocol, which could limit its adoption in certain environments.
Performance Overhead: The use of a hash function in SAE can add additional computational overhead, which can affect the performance of the protocol. This could be an issue in high-traffic environments, where performance is critical.
Vulnerability to Timing Attacks: SAE is vulnerable to timing attacks, where an attacker can measure the time it takes for the authentication process to complete and use this information to infer the password. This vulnerability can be mitigated through proper implementation and configuration of the protocol, but it remains a potential concern.
Limited Adoption: While SAE has been adopted as the key establishment protocol for the latest version of the Wi-Fi Protected Access (WPA) security standard, it is still relatively new and has not yet been widely adopted by all manufacturers and devices.

While SAE offers improved security over traditional key establishment protocols, there are some potential disadvantages to consider. Proper implementation and configuration of the protocol is important to ensure its effectiveness and minimize potential vulnerabilities.

SAE vs the alternatives

Here’s a comparison table between Simultaneous Authentication of Equals (SAE) and some of the alternative key establishment protocols:

Protocol	Advantages	Disadvantages
Simultaneous Authentication of Equals (SAE)	Stronger security, protection against dictionary attacks, mutual authentication, forward secrecy, compatibility with existing infrastructure	Compatibility issues with older devices, potential performance overhead, vulnerability to timing attacks, limited adoption
Pre-Shared Key (PSK)	Easy to implement, widely supported	Vulnerable to dictionary attacks, same key is used by all clients, difficult to manage and update passwords, potential for key theft
802.1X/EAP	Provides user authentication, supports a variety of authentication methods	Requires additional infrastructure (RADIUS server), more complex to implement, potential for configuration errors and security vulnerabilities
Certificate-based authentication (EAP-TLS)	Strong security, mutual authentication, support for a wide range of client and server authentication methods	Requires certificates to be deployed and managed, additional infrastructure required, potential for configuration errors and security vulnerabilities

As the table shows, SAE offers stronger security than PSK and is compatible with existing Wi-Fi infrastructure, but may have some compatibility and performance overhead issues. 802.1X/EAP and certificate-based authentication are both more complex to implement and require additional infrastructure, but offer more flexibility and support for a wider range of authentication methods.

It’s important to note that the choice of key establishment protocol will depend on the specific needs and requirements of the network, and each protocol has its own strengths and weaknesses. Ultimately, the best approach is to carefully consider the options and select the protocol that offers the most appropriate balance of security, usability, and compatibility for the specific use case.

Network Security Group Azure: How Does It Work?

WPA3 SAE

WPA3 SAE stands for Wi-Fi Protected Access 3 (WPA3) Simultaneous Authentication of Equals (SAE). It is a security protocol that is used to protect wireless networks, providing enhanced security features compared to its predecessor, WPA2.

SAE is the key exchange protocol used in WPA3, which enables devices to securely establish a shared secret key for encrypting wireless communications. The key exchange process in WPA3 SAE is designed to be resistant to offline dictionary attacks and brute-force attacks, providing stronger security against unauthorized access to the Wi-Fi network.

WPA3 SAE introduces a concept called “Opportunistic Wireless Encryption” which aims to provide encrypted communication even in open Wi-Fi networks where no passphrase is required. With SAE, devices can establish an encrypted connection without the need for a pre-shared key or passphrase, making it more convenient and secure for users.

Overall, WPA3 SAE improves the security of Wi-Fi networks by enhancing the key exchange process and providing stronger encryption methods, helping to protect against various types of attacks and unauthorized access.

What is SAE Transition Mode?

SAE Transition Mode refers to a feature introduced in the Wi-Fi Alliance’s WPA3 certification program. It is designed to facilitate the migration from WPA2 to WPA3 while maintaining backward compatibility with older devices that do not support the new security protocol.

In SAE Transition Mode, a Wi-Fi network can simultaneously support both WPA2 and WPA3 security modes. This allows devices with WPA2 support to connect using the existing security protocol, while devices with WPA3 support can take advantage of the enhanced security features offered by WPA3.

The transition mode enables a gradual upgrade of devices in a network, allowing organizations and users to adopt WPA3 without immediately replacing all their existing devices. It provides flexibility and ensures that connectivity is maintained for devices that have not yet been upgraded to WPA3.

However, it’s important to note that while SAE Transition Mode provides backward compatibility, the security level for devices using WPA2 remains the same as in traditional WPA2 networks. The enhanced security features of WPA3 are only applicable to devices that support and use the WPA3 security protocol.

SAE Passphrase

In the context of Wi-Fi security, SAE (Simultaneous Authentication of Equals) does not involve the use of a passphrase like the previous WPA2 security protocol. Instead, SAE utilizes a key exchange protocol to establish a shared secret key between the access point (AP) and the client device.

In WPA2, a passphrase is used to generate a cryptographic key known as the Pre-Shared Key (PSK). This key is then used for authentication and encryption purposes. However, SAE eliminates the need for a fixed passphrase and instead employs a secure key exchange mechanism.

What is a PKI (Public Key Infrastructure)?

During the SAE key exchange process, the AP and client device perform a mutual authentication by proving that they possess the correct cryptographic keys without directly revealing them. This authentication process establishes a shared secret key, which is used to encrypt the Wi-Fi communication.

By removing the reliance on a static passphrase, SAE offers improved security against dictionary attacks and offline password cracking attempts. The key exchange process is designed to be resistant to various types of attacks, providing stronger security for wireless networks.

Frequent Asked Questions

What does SAE mean in Wi-Fi?

SAE stands for Simultaneous Authentication of Equals, which is a security protocol used in Wi-Fi networks to establish a secure connection between devices.

How does Simultaneous Authentication of Equals work?

SAE works by allowing both the client device and the access point to generate a shared secret key at the same time. This process is resistant to offline dictionary attacks, which is one of the primary weaknesses of other key exchange methods such as WPA2.

What are the benefits of using Simultaneous Authentication of Equals?

The benefits of using SAE include stronger security and protection against offline dictionary attacks, faster connection times, and better compatibility with IoT devices that may not support other key exchange methods.

How do I set up Simultaneous Authentication of Equals?

The specific steps to set up SAE will depend on the hardware and software you are using. Generally, SAE can be enabled by selecting it as the preferred key exchange method in the Wi-Fi network settings.

What are some best practices for using Simultaneous Authentication of Equals?

Some best practices for using SAE include using strong passwords or passphrases, updating firmware and software regularly to ensure compatibility and security patches, and using other security measures such as firewalls and antivirus software in addition to SAE.

Are there any drawbacks to using Simultaneous Authentication of Equals?

One potential drawback of SAE is that it may not be supported by all devices or networks, which could limit compatibility. Additionally, SAE is not foolproof and may still be vulnerable to attacks if other security measures are not in place.

SAE Wpa3: How does SAE work in WPA3?

SAE is the primary key exchange method used in WPA3, which is the latest version of the Wi-Fi Protected Access security protocol. SAE replaces the older pre-shared key (PSK) method used in WPA2.

What does SAE transition mode mean?

SAE transition mode allows devices that do not support SAE to connect to a Wi-Fi network that uses SAE. This is accomplished by falling back to the older PSK method for those devices, while still allowing newer devices to use SAE.

There you have it, an overview of SAE and its use in WPA3. While it is a powerful tool for providing enhanced security, it’s important to be aware of the potential compatibility issues when using this protocol. Additionally, remember that other security measures should also be taken to ensure optimal protection against attacks. Ultimately, taking a comprehensive approach to cybersecurity will help you keep your network safe.

Information Security Asia

Information Security Asia is the go-to website for the latest cybersecurity and tech news in various sectors. Our expert writers provide insights and analysis that you can trust, so you can stay ahead of the curve and protect your business. Whether you are a small business, an enterprise or even a government agency, we have the latest updates and advice for all aspects of cybersecurity.