Short answer: use the strongest method each account supports. In order: a passkey or hardware security key, then an authenticator app (or push with number matching), then SMS or voice codes only as a last resort. Any two-factor method beats a password alone, so turn something on today and upgrade later.
Last reviewed: November 2026.
Why the method matters
Two-factor authentication, or 2FA, asks for something beyond your password. The goal is that a stolen password alone is not enough. But attackers have adapted: they trick people into handing over codes, flood them with approval prompts, or take over their phone numbers. That is why CISA, the US cybersecurity agency, distinguishes between phishing-resistant multi-factor authentication and the weaker forms, and ranks them. Its fact sheet puts FIDO and WebAuthn authentication first, app-based codes and push approvals with number matching next, push without number matching after that, and SMS and voice codes last, describing them as a last-resort option.
The methods, from weakest to strongest
SMS and voice codes
How it works: a short code is texted or read out to your phone.
Weaknesses: codes can be redirected through a SIM swap, intercepted by malware, or typed into a fake login page that relays them to the real site. Messages also pass through the phone network, which you do not control.
When it is acceptable: when a service offers nothing else, or for low-value accounts. Protect your number with a carrier lock as described in our SIM swap guide.
Push approvals
How it works: your phone shows a prompt and you tap Approve.
Weaknesses: attackers with your password can send prompt after prompt, hoping a tired or confused user taps yes, a tactic called push bombing or MFA fatigue. Plain approve or deny prompts are weaker than versions that make you type a number shown on the login screen.
Tip: choose number matching where offered, and never approve a prompt you did not start.
Authenticator apps (TOTP)
How it works: an app generates a six-digit code that changes every thirty seconds, based on a secret shared once when you set up the account. Codes are created on your device and do not travel by phone network.
Weaknesses: a convincing fake site can ask for the code and pass it on within seconds, so these are not fully phishing-resistant. Losing your phone without a backup can lock you out.
Verdict: a solid upgrade over SMS and the best option for most accounts that do not offer passkeys or keys.
Hardware security keys
How it works: you plug in or tap a small device. The key checks the website address before it responds, so a lookalike site receives nothing.
Weaknesses: cost, the need to carry one, and the need to register a spare.
Verdict: the strongest widely available option, ideal for email, password managers and administrators.
Passkeys
Passkeys use the same cryptographic principle as security keys but are stored on your phone, computer or password manager, which makes them far easier to adopt. See our explanation of how passkeys work.
What to use where
- Email, password manager, Apple, Google or Microsoft account: passkey or security key if available, otherwise an authenticator app. These accounts unlock everything else.
- Banking and investments: the strongest option the bank offers, ideally an app or key. Be cautious if the only option is SMS.
- Social media and shopping: an authenticator app.
- Everything else: whatever is offered, SMS included, rather than nothing.
- Businesses: follow CISA’s guidance and move administrators and remote access to phishing-resistant methods first.
Set it up without locking yourself out
- Enable 2FA on your email account first.
- Save the recovery codes the service shows you, in a password manager or on paper in a safe place.
- Register a second method or a second device where possible. Buy two security keys and register both.
- When you change phones, transfer your authenticator accounts before wiping the old one. Many apps offer encrypted backup.
- Keep your carrier and email accounts protected, since both are recovery routes.
Frequently asked questions
Is SMS two-factor authentication better than nothing?
Yes. It stops a large share of automated attacks that rely on a stolen password. It is just the weakest of the options, so upgrade where you can.
Can attackers bypass authenticator apps?
Yes, through real-time phishing that relays the code, or by stealing a logged-in session. That is why security keys and passkeys are rated higher.
What if I lose my phone?
Use your saved recovery codes or a second registered method. Without them, recovery can be slow or impossible, so set this up in advance.
Do I need a separate authenticator app for each account?
No. One app can hold many accounts, and some password managers include codes, though keeping codes separate from passwords gives you more protection if the manager is compromised.
Sources and further reading
- CISA, Implementing Phishing-Resistant MFA fact sheet: cisa.gov
- FIDO Alliance, how passkeys and security keys work: fidoalliance.org



